Is it Possible to Fix a Broken Toilet Tank Lid?
Nov 19, 2026
We occasionally get requests from customers seeking to send us their broken/chipped/cracked tank tops, thinking that we can fix it for them. Fixing a tank lid is not really possible. Porcelain is very similar to glass. Once a tank lid breaks, there is no way to cover up a crack without seeing it. While we have seen photos of customers who have temporarily glued a lid back together, we specialize in replacing broken lids rather than fixing them. We have sources for toilet tank lids all over the country and stock most every toilet tank lid in every color it was made. In the event we don't have the lid you need, we can usually make a new one to fit in its place.Â
Customers also break or crack their toilet tanks, and a temporary repair should be avoided at all costs. You may be able to temporarily seal up the tank to hold water without it leaking, but that seal will eventually fail, and the way the world works it is most likely going to happen while you are at work, asleep, or on vacation, and the water damage from a flooding toilet will be an expensive repair that could involve more than just the toilet. In the event that your tank cracks and a new tank or toilet isn't available right away, we recommend turning off the water supply to the toilet, and if the toilet must be used, turn the water back on temporarily just to flush the toilet, and then turn it back off. Be sure to drain all of the water out of the tank by holding the handle down until it is empty to reduce the amount of water leaking from a cracked tank.Â
Our goal is to help you keep your toilet by supplying replacement but like new vintage tank lids and tanks. That is usually the most economical way to repair it rather than replace it, and keeps the old toilet out of a landfill.Â
